Skip to main content
AI

Four prompts that make AI challenge your marketing brief

November 20263 min read

AI can produce objections at speed. Deciding which ones matter is your job.

Ask AI to find what is wrong with your brief, and it usually will. This pattern gives you four prompts to do that, then leaves the final call with you.

Why the brief needs a challenger

Anthropic found that AI could sometimes become too agreeable on emotionally charged topics, confirming the user's perspective rather than challenging it. The practical step follows from that: ask AI specifically to challenge your assumptions, and you tend to get a better conversation.

The second reason concerns who does the judging. A large creativity study published in Scientific Reports found that AI outperformed the average participant on creativity tests. The quality of the result still depends on the person, on the taste and judgement needed to select the right idea. AI can produce objections at speed. Deciding which ones matter is your job.

The example brief

To show the pattern at work, take a brief for a spring campaign for a group of local offices. The brief assumes customers choose on price. Each step below uses that brief.

The four steps, with prompts

1. State your bet

Paste the brief and write, in one sentence, what you believe will make it work. Writing the bet down gives the AI something specific to test.

Example prompt:

“Here is our spring campaign brief for a group of local offices. My bet: this campaign will work because customers choose on price, so a clear spring offer will bring them in.”

2. Ask for the weak spots

Ask the AI to name the three assumptions in the brief most likely to be wrong, and why. Asking for a fixed number stops it from padding the answer or softening it into general advice.

Example prompt:

“Name the three assumptions in this brief most likely to be wrong. For each one, explain why it might not hold. Do not suggest fixes yet.”

For the spring brief, the price assumption is the obvious candidate to test. Let the AI find the other two rather than guiding it.

3. Switch seats

Ask the AI to argue against the brief as a sceptical customer would. This moves the critique from the planning table to the person the campaign has to reach.

Example prompt:

“You are a sceptical customer who lives near one of these local offices. Read the brief and argue against it. Tell me why this spring campaign would not make you get in touch.”

If the customer's objections have little to do with price, you have learned something about the bet you wrote in step one.

4. Decide and write it down

Go through each assumption the AI raised. Keep it or change it, and note why. The decision stays with you.

Example prompt:

“Here are my decisions on the three assumptions. For each, I have noted whether I keep or change it and why. Summarise them as a short list I can attach to the brief.”

For the spring campaign, that list might record whether price stays as the main message, what changes in the copy if it does not, and the reasoning behind each choice.

What to keep from the pattern

Save the four prompts, swap in your own brief, and keep the written decisions next to the brief for the next person who opens it.

Sources: Anthropic, How people ask Claude for personal guidance (30 Apr 2026). Bellemare-Pepin et al., Divergent creativity in humans and large language models, Scientific Reports (21 Jan 2026).

Mimmi Liljegren
Founder & CEO, Ayra

Want results like these?

Book a demo and see an agent trained on your brand.